Agnosticism
Agnosticism
Introduction
Agnosticism is the view that the existence of a divine being, the supernatural or ultimate reality is unknown or unknowable【339204656926742†L357-L360】. This perspective does not assert either belief or disbelief in gods; instead, it suspends judgment. Thomas Henry Huxley introduced the term “agnostic” in the 19th century as a method of intellectual honesty—encouraging people not to profess certainty without evidence【339204656926742†L357-L368】. As a learner, you will explore why some questions may remain beyond human comprehension and how agnosticism differs from both atheism and theism.
Knowing what we cannot know
Huxley defined agnosticism as a method rather than a creed. According to this method, you should not claim knowledge when there is insufficient rational justification【339204656926742†L357-L364】. Strong agnostics argue that human reason will never resolve questions about divine existence, while weak agnostics simply note that such knowledge is currently unattained. By understanding these distinctions, you can better appreciate the nuance behind statements like “I don’t know” and recognise that uncertainty can be a responsible position.
Variations and related concepts
Agnosticism can be applied not only to questions about gods but also to broader metaphysical or supernatural claims. It often overlaps with skepticism, empiricism and humanism, emphasising the need for evidence and the limitations of human cognition. You might also learn about terms such as ignosticism (questioning the coherence of the concept of God) and weak atheism (simply lacking belief) to see how agnosticism fits within the spectrum of belief and knowledge.
Agnosticism in practice
Living as an agnostic can influence your attitude toward debates about religion, science and ethics. You may prioritise open inquiry, dialogue and respect for different views, while avoiding dogmatic pronouncements. This position can encourage humility and curiosity, prompting you to seek evidence where possible and to acknowledge uncertainty where necessary.
Interactive Tasks
Quiz: Test Your Knowledge
What does agnosticism claim about the existence of gods? (That it is unknown or unknowable) (!That gods definitely exist) (!That gods definitely do not exist) (!That gods are irrelevant)
Who coined the term “agnostic”? (Thomas Henry Huxley) (!Friedrich Nietzsche) (!Bertrand Russell) (!Albert Camus)
What distinguishes strong agnosticism from weak agnosticism? (Strong agnosticism claims knowledge of gods is impossible, weak agnosticism claims it is currently unknown) (!Strong agnostics are believers, weak agnostics are atheists) (!There is no difference) (!Weak agnostics claim absolute certainty)
Which philosophy emphasises withholding certainty without evidence? (Agnosticism) (!Gnosticism) (!Polytheism) (!Deism)
How does agnosticism differ from atheism? (Agnosticism suspends judgment while atheism lacks belief) (!Agnosticism asserts belief in many gods) (!Agnosticism denies all knowledge) (!There is no difference)
What does ignosticism question? (The coherence of the concept of God) (!The existence of moral values) (!The validity of mathematics) (!The history of philosophy)
Why might agnosticism encourage humility? (Because it acknowledges the limits of human understanding) (!Because it rejects all forms of evidence) (!Because it insists on certainty) (!Because it demands conversion)
Which movement emphasises that knowledge comes from experience? (Empiricism) (!Dualism) (!Idealism) (!Determinism)
What attitude does agnosticism promote toward debates? (Open inquiry and respectful dialogue) (!Dogmatic pronouncements) (!Aggressive proselytising) (!Avoiding all discussion)
How can agnosticism apply beyond questions about gods? (It can be applied to any metaphysical or supernatural claims) (!It only applies to physics) (!It only applies to art) (!It cannot apply to anything else)
Memory
| Agnosticism | View that the existence of gods is unknown or unknowable |
| Huxley | Coined the term “agnostic” in the 19th century |
| Strong agnosticism | Claim that knowledge of gods is impossible |
| Weak agnosticism | Claim that knowledge of gods is currently unknown |
| Empiricism | Doctrine that knowledge comes from experience |
Drag and Drop
| Assign the correct terms | Description |
|---|---|
| Agnosticism | Suspends judgment about divine existence |
| Huxley | Introduced the term “agnostic” |
| Strong agnosticism | Claims knowledge of gods is impossible |
| Weak agnosticism | Asserts that knowledge of gods is currently unknown |
| Ignosticism | Questions whether the concept of God is coherent |
Crossword Puzzle
| Agnosticism | View that divine existence is unknown |
| Huxley | Agnostic who coined the term |
| Unknown | Not known or beyond knowledge |
| Knowledge | Justified true belief |
| Belief | Acceptance without proof |
| Skepticism | Doubting claims without evidence |
LearningApps
Cloze Text
Open Tasks
Easy
- Opinion piece: Write a short article about why admitting “I don’t know” can be a sign of strength.
- Vocabulary activity: Create flashcards for terms like agnosticism, atheism, theism and skepticism.
- Infographic: Design an infographic explaining the difference between strong and weak agnosticism.
Standard
- Comparative analysis: Compare agnosticism with atheism, deism and theism in a table.
- Research project: Investigate the life of Thomas Henry Huxley and his contributions to science and philosophy.
- Discussion: Lead a classroom discussion on whether knowledge of the divine is possible.
Hard
- Analytical essay: Assess the merits and drawbacks of strong versus weak agnosticism.
- Survey: Survey your community on their attitudes toward religious knowledge and summarise the findings.
- Creative story: Write a short story featuring a character who embodies agnosticism and their journey of inquiry.
Learning control
- Position spectrum: Describe how agnosticism fits between atheism and theism on a spectrum of belief and knowledge.
- Method of inquiry: Explain why Huxley saw agnosticism as a method rather than a doctrine.
- Epistemic humility: Discuss how agnosticism encourages humility in debates about religion and science.
- Application: Apply agnostic reasoning to a non‑religious metaphysical claim and evaluate the result.
- Terminology: Define and distinguish between agnosticism, ignosticism and apatheism.
OERs on the Topic
Media
Links
Share - Discuss
Schulfach+
|
|
aiMOOCs
aiMOOC Projekte
|
|
THE MONKEY DANCE
|
|
|
|
 |
Sponsoren, Förderer, Kooperationspartner
Children for a better world >> Förderung der AI Fair-Image Challenge
Fair-Image wird von CHILDREN JUGEND HILFT! gefördert und ist mit der deutschlandweiten AI Fair-Image Challenge SIEGERPROJEKT 2025. Alle Infos zur Challenge hier >>. Infos zum Camp25 gibt es hier. Wenn auch Ihr Euch ehrenamtlich engagiert und noch finanzielle Unterstützung für Eurer Projekt braucht, dann stellt gerne einen Antrag bei JUGEND HILFT.
